Many people are drawn to solar power, and for good reason. It brings lower energy bills, greater independence, and a smaller carbon footprint. However, the truth is that solar energy isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution. Several factors can make a particular home unsuitable for a solar panel system. From shading and roof direction to the roof’s condition and the overall financial picture, there are important considerations.
Obstructions and orientation
For solar panels to work, they need sunlight. Maximising direct sunlight is key to getting the most bang for your buck from a solar system. However, not all rooftops are created equal when it comes to catching those precious rays. Shade from trees, neighbouring buildings, or even parts of your own house can dramatically reduce the amount of energy your panels produce, impacting your savings and overall viability of the investment.
Imagine your roof being partially or completely in shadow for a significant part of the day. Even partial shading can have a disproportionately large impact on the output of traditional solar systems. This means you might not generate enough energy to offset your usage, and the return on your investment could take much longer than anticipated.
While technologies like microinverters and power optimisers can help, they add to the overall cost of the system and aren’t a complete solution for consistently shaded roofs.
Roof orientation challenges
In the Southern Hemisphere, the sun tracks across the northern sky. This means that a north-facing roof receives the most direct sunlight throughout the day, making it the prime real estate for solar panel installation. Panels installed on east or west-facing roofs will still generate power, but their output will be less consistent, and the peak generation times might not align with your household’s peak energy usage. On the other hand, south-facing roofs receive very little direct sunlight and are generally not suitable for solar panel installation.
While it might be possible to install panels on multiple roof sections with different orientations to capture more sunlight, this can increase the complexity and cost of the installation. Ideally, a significant portion of the roof should have a clear, unshaded, north-facing aspect to make solar a great investment.
Structural limitations
Solar panels, along with their mounting structures, aren’t feather-light. Depending on the size of the system and the materials used, they can add a significant amount of weight to your roof. Older homes, or those built with lighter construction methods, might not have the structural capacity to handle this additional load safely. Installing panels on a roof that can’t bear the weight could lead to sagging, leaks, or even more serious structural damage over time.
Age and wear
Solar panel systems are designed to last for years. It makes little sense to install them on a roof that’s nearing the end of its lifespan. If your roof is old, has existing damage like leaks or missing tiles, or shows signs of significant wear and tear, you’ll likely need to replace or repair it before considering solar.
Roof types and compatibility
The type of material your roof is made from can also present challenges for solar installation. While most common roofing materials like tile, metal, and asphalt shingles are generally compatible with solar panels, some materials can make the process more complex or costly.
Costs and ROI
Installing a solar panel system involves a significant upfront cost. While government rebates and incentives can help offset these initial expenses, the out-of-pocket cost can still be substantial.
For homeowners whose properties have limitations, the initial investment can climb even higher. In these scenarios, the amount of electricity generated might not be enough to recoup the increased costs within a reasonable timeframe. The “payback period,” the time it takes for your savings to equal your initial investment, could become too long to be financially worthwhile, especially if you plan to move within a few years.
The financial benefits of solar are also closely tied to how much electricity you use and the feed-in tariffs (FiTs) offered in your state or territory for excess energy exported back to the grid. FiTs are credits you receive for the surplus electricity your solar system generates that you don’t use yourself.
If your household has relatively low electricity consumption during the day, you might export a significant portion of your solar generation. If the FiT is low, the financial returns on this exported energy might not be substantial enough to justify the initial investment in solar.
On the other hand, if your energy consumption is high and occurs mainly at night, you’ll rely less on self-generated solar power and more on grid electricity, even with panels installed. In such cases, the savings from solar might be less significant, lengthening the payback period.
Regulatory and practical hurdles
Beyond the physical characteristics of a property and the financial considerations, certain regulations and practical limitations can also stand in the way of a smooth solar panel installation.
Local council regulations can sometimes impose restrictions on the installation of solar panels. These might relate to the visual impact of the panels, particularly in heritage-protected areas or on historically significant buildings. Councils might have specific guidelines regarding the size, placement, and even the colour of solar panels to preserve the aesthetic character of the neighbourhood or the building itself.
If your property is heritage-listed, obtaining approval for solar panel installation can be a lengthy and complex process, and in some cases, permission might even be denied if the panels are deemed to negatively impact the building’s historical significance.
Space limitations
While the desire for clean energy might be strong, the physical size of your roof can be a limiting factor. Homes with very small roof spaces might simply not have enough to accommodate a solar panel system large enough to generate a significant amount of electricity and provide meaningful savings.
Even with high-efficiency panels, a certain amount of surface area is required to produce a worthwhile amount of power. If your roof is small or has many obstructions like skylights, vents, or chimneys that further reduce usable space, the potential energy generation from a solar system might be too limited to justify the investment.
Grid connection challenges
While less common in established urban areas, some properties, particularly those in more remote or rural locations, might face challenges with grid connection. If the local electricity grid infrastructure is inadequate or far from your property, the cost and complexity of connecting your solar system to the grid to export excess energy can be prohibitive. This can significantly impact the financial viability of solar, as you might not be able to take advantage of FiTs.
Despite Australia’s sunny climate, solar panels aren’t a universal fit. Shade, non-north-facing roofs, structural weaknesses, and poor roof condition can hinder energy production and increase costs. Financially, high upfront investments, low daytime energy use, and unfavourable feed-in tariffs can impact returns. Regulatory and practical issues like council restrictions or small roof spaces can also be barriers. Ultimately, a careful assessment of your property and financial situation is key. Consulting solar professionals will help determine if solar is the right energy solution for your Australian home.
Energy Matters has been in the solar industry since 2005 and has helped over 40,000 Australian households in their journey to energy independence.
Complete our quick Solar Quote Quiz to receive up to 3 FREE solar quotes from trusted local installers – it’ll only take you a few minutes and is completely obligation-free.
